Please have a look at our Forum Rules. Lets keep this forum an enjoyable place to visit.
There is much talk about absolute pitch and relative pitch. The absolute, where you can identify directly one note based on just hearing it on any instrument, while relative hearing is more about identifying the note with the help of having identified nearby notes.
I am going to discuss another phenomenon that seems to be my case more than absolute or relative, and since I have not heard of it before, I will name it simply
If I hear a note played *on violin* I can without making any sound or trying, IF and ONLY IF I have the violin in the hand supported normally on the left shoulder, instantly find the position of the played note (without any trials, the finger goes directly to the correct place). This is obviously some kind of muscular hearing, because its not my ear or my brain who recognizes the note, but the muscles. And I really have to hold the violin in normal position.
Can anybody explain this phenomenon and how to take advantage of it? (I am not a person with good intonation in general.)
I am jealous! I am very weak at playing by ear. I can get close, usually one or two notes high. And then I will play it as sharp when it is supposed to be natural, play it as natural when it should be flat. I am getting better at it though.
You could learn songs this way, especially if you can slow the music down and play one note behind the music. Maybe.
Muscular memory isn't anything new. It's how many guitar players play. Jimi Hendrix actually talked about this way back when. When you''re hearing the tones of the music in your head your hands just go in the right place because of knowing your hand positions well.
I would say keep practicing all the hand positions on the violin. Don't get stuck in first position because then your muscular memory is being very limited. Yes, you can compare it to typing on a keyboard too. Once you learn to type well, your fingers just flow over the right letter without thinking about it. It's all about the correct position.
Dave, you made a great comment…If you have the tools to slow down music while keeping the same pitch, it's a great way to learn a song by ear.
Most Users Ever Online: 231
Currently Browsing this Page:
Guest Posters: 1
Newest Members:Anandas hands, Timothyphofs, lisaxp16, AntonyKag, HenryDeedo, MoshnenkoFloma
Administrators: Fiddlerman: 12071, KindaScratchy: 1675, BillyG: 1865