Please have a look at our Forum Rules. Lets keep this forum an enjoyable place to visit.
Wondering what everyone's experiences are in playing other instruments?
My story is that I started violin last year with an instructor. I am naturally left-handed, but there are not many options with the violin and I didn't have any trouble starting out right handed. At the same time, I was learning guitar on my own but playing left-handed. This month, I decided to start taking guitar lessons, but my violin teacher recommended that I learn right handed to keep so that the skills learned would be more compatible with playing the violin. I am trying, but holding the guitar right handed is very awkward and the rhythm is not coming very naturally - however, I can see where the fretboard fingering skills would transfer to both instruments. The rhythm hand is quite different from guitar to violin.
What about you guys? What are your experiences with learning other instruments and their compatibility with the violin?
I took piano lessons around age 6 or 7. Don't remember exactly why they ended. I took up cornet around 6th or 7th grade. When I got into Jr. High, the bandmaster let us know that he had about 15 applicants for trumpet/cornet, and 5 slots, and he had a shortage of French Horn players. I wasn't anything outstanding on the cornet, so I switched to French Horn. I was actually fairly good at that, but the high school I went to was what they nowadays call a magnet school (it was an experimental idea, then) and the band director had the attitude that if you weren't in the music cluster, you weren't worth spending any time on, so I never got much encouragement or a chance to move up. French Horns were expensive, too, so I didn't play it any more after I got out of high school.
Somewhere in that I picked up guitar and got a little bit of amateur teaching. That's probably the one instrument I've played the longest, but I've never been particularly good. For many years, my hobby was buying musical instruments in the hopes that that would be the one I actually had some talent at, so at one time or another, I've had (or currently have): cornet, French Horn, flute, harmonica, ocarina, acoustic guitar (both nylon and steel string), electric guitar, electric bass, 3 or 4 kinds of drums, alto recorder, and of course most recently, violin and viola. (I've probably forgotten a few.)
My experience with the violin has shown me something. I'm a lousy teacher of instruments that I myself don't know how to play. Especially when I'm also the student. Some people can pick up an instrument they've never met before, and with little or no help, teach themselves to play it, and play it well. I'm not one of them. Having a teacher for the violin has made a huge difference.
Another thing that has helped a lot has been that for most of those instruments, I had things I wanted to play. I got the instrument in question because I wanted to be able to play certain songs (or parts of songs) that I liked. With violin, there weren't any preconceived likes and dislikes. That meant that I've been much more ok with the rate of progress I've been making (slow, but acceptable for the amount of practice I've put in), whereas with most of the others, I'd get frustrated because the gap between what I could do and what I wanted to do was huge and not getting appreciably smaller no matter what I did.
I took accordion lessons in grade school. Tried to play cornet in the middle school orchestra for about a year until the music teacher told me that I didn't have the right lips to play the cornet. Sold the cornet and bought a guitar. Played the guitar for the next 50 years. Several years ago I started making some Native American style wooden flutes and play those. Then learned to play the penny whistle for a year or two. About 3 years ago I bought a violin and have been trying to learn to play that.
A positive attitude may not solve all your problems, but it will annoy enough people to make it worth the effort. ~Herm Albright
@Fran I bet they do, I know some of my friends kids still play them in school.. hang on let me see if I can find one....
Ah, yep... this one looks like the one I played as a kid (I got my brothers hand-me-down, haha) https://www.amazon.com/First-Note-FN153-Firstnote-Flutophone/dp/B000EEHE5G/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1496933693&sr=8-1&keywords=flutophone
My 2 older brothers had a nicer looking black one, I think that's packed away somewhere, too, haha.
Most Users Ever Online: 231
Currently Online: ~Rea
Currently Browsing this Page:
Kevin M.: 1957
Guest Posters: 1
Newest Members:Charlesraw, letako18, nathannu4, ChesterDuH, jeanninemv60, Carloshef
Administrators: Fiddlerman: 12325, KindaScratchy: 1687, BillyG: 1996