Since December I have been using a set of synthetic core Pirastro Tonica silver wound strings.  Since December I have been very happy with them. Nice quality sound, good response,  and great for a wide variety of music styles. They are strong, they stay in tune, and all in all I give them an A+.

last night I joticed that the winding on my D string started to come unraveled near the upper end of thhe fingerboard. . This was causing the string to make a tinny fuzzy sound, particularly if I played it open. It may have unravelled itself from wear and tear (sometimes I can play kind of hard) or, when I accidentally bumped the fingerboard against the edge of my music stand.

I didn't have an extra D so, I head over to the local music shop and buy a replacement D. He deals mostly in student grade strings, does not carry Pirastro or any of the common brands so I end up buying on off brand (brand I am not familiar with) for about 4 bucks that he broke out of a set.. Hey, how bad can it be I figure, right ? I figure it will tide me over so I can practice till I get a good string.

Well, here goes. I am very experienced at installing strings, been doing it all my life pretty much and I understand how to put on strings correctly and bring them up to pitch.  Well, I am about halfway to proper pitch and SNAP!!, the string breaks between the tail piece and the bridge. I mean it didn't break at the end or where the string runs over the bridge or anything. It just snapped and it wasn't even tightened anywhere near

Well, Monday he is getting this string back regardless of whether I get my money back or not, regardless of whether I get a replacement or not.  That music store has been inmy home town for decades, since I was a kid, and even as a youngster I remember he always sold crappy strings. I should have known better than to buy a string there.  In the meantime I am putting my old Tonica D string back on so at least I can practice.  And I just placed an order with Fiddlerman for a replacement Tonica D which will fit along with the set I have on the violin.

I don;t know if the strings are simply junk, or maybe have been sitting on the shelf for too long or what.  I have never had a string break on me like that. 

Sorry for my diatraibe but I just had to vent a bit. Anyone else experience bad strings ??

Kevin, I agree. I wanted to order a full set but I am running a bit low on money right now.  But as soon as I can I am going to order another full set.  I like the Pirastro Tonica's so far but I might try a different set just so I can compare them. After all, the only way I can get to know which strings I like best is by trying different ones.

Thanks for the recommendation on the Pro-Arte's. I might give them a try.

myguitarnow said
I am all familiar with breaking strings on guitar anyways but I bend the heck out of them. It's hard for me to picture a D violin string snapping like that. Maybe he sold you a used string that had a kink in the area that broke. If it broke between the tail piece and the bridge is there still room to maybe tie a knot so you can use it until you can buy new strings?

He pulled it out of a  supposedly "new set" but who knows.  The music store I went to sells mostly drum and guitar and accessories. They probably have a very low turnover in violin related stuff so, who knows, it''s entirely possible  the string may have been sitting on the shelf for a decade or two. 

In any event I have a new string on order.  Thanks for the idea of knotting the string. It might still be long enough to use since it broke pretty close to the tailpiece.  I'll give it a try.

cdennyb said
A perfect example of why, when you find the "perfect string set" for your instrument… you make up two sets. After all… shelf life of 6-10 months will be perfect for you, when it comes time to change strings at 6 months or whatever, you use your back up set and at a convient time reorder another set for spares and backup. You will always have the "right" string and it'll be in your box ready to use in a minute flat.

shipping would be basically the same cost on two sets. Why take a chance.

Yeah, that is what I normally do.  However, due to recent bills and expenses I fell behind and wound up without backup strings. So, I'll just have to make do with my old D till the new one gets here.

The funny part of the story is that this particular music store has been around here for over 40 years. When I first took up the violin at the age of 10 I used to avoid buying strings there because they would either always break instantly or, soon after I put them on.  Instead I used to ask my Dad to buy me strings from a store down in new York City where he worked.   I haven't bought a string from this music store since around 1968 or 1969.  Now, I come there 40+ years later and I I get a lousy string.  Maybe they don't like violin players ?   Well all i can say on their behalf is they have been consistent over the decades. They sold crappy violin  strings in 1968 and they are still going strong.  They have stood the sest of time, thats for sure.