Please have a look at our Forum Rules. Lets keep this forum an enjoyable place to visit.
In an ideal universe it should be perfectly vertical, supposedly we find a norm to define the "horizontal plane" first.
Once or twice a year it's not bad to visit a luthier to address such issues. However I would be concerned more if the soundpost is not touching the plates of the instrument properly and fully, rather than being perfectly vertical, in order to avoid damaging the instrument. If no luthier is available, I would extremely carefully dare to look with a dental mirror. But this could kick back, if you accidentally touch the post, and bring it down 🙁
Was it once straight and suddenly you noticed it was moved?
A photo would help. Two photos, would be better. One from the fingerboard to the tailpiece and one from the treble to the bass side of the instrument 🙂
Thanks for the advice guys!
Mostly I am asking out of curiosity. I'm not sure if the sound post was perfectly straight before but it is at a silght angle relative to the bridge and the bridge is at a right angle relative to the top plate. As far as I can tell the violin sounds fine and I can tune it without problems. I'll see if I can get some pictures of the sound post. Also it is good to know that visiting a luthier is an option as I am new to this world things concerning violins. My guess is that there is no problem with it. I think it would be fun to get an inexpensive violin and play with sound post adjusting before I try anything on this instrument. Thanks again Hermes and Fiddlerman!
Pierre, this thing with the fork, is a real lifehack... 🙂 I've never thought of it before...I own some soundpost setters but now that I'm stuck with this fork thing I guess that you can also bend it into the proper shape
Chrisramo3, getting a cheaper instrument to experiment on is always great, and will definitely help you understand the instrument...Now as far as you post is concerned, you know, having your instrument checked every once in a while by somebody you trust, is like fine-tuning your car...(and making sure it's safe). I would have it checked just to relax if I was really occupied with the thought, and make sure that my instrument is at it's full potential...
I see what you mean by not straight. As an experiment I would move the bridge back so that it is not perfectly aligned with the notches on the f holes; move it back just far enough so that the bottom right foot is covering a bit of the sound post surface area.
Then test to see if you like the sound.
my logic behind this is perhaps the shape of the sound post is in fact making full contact with the top and back of the fiddle albeit slanted. By adjusting the bridge you can improve the violin.
or you'll completely knock down the sound post, but if your taking it to a luthier/violin repair man a fallen sound post is already an inevitable incident.
Questions : has it always been like that? is it a nice violin?
idealistic rhetoric : is it possible that a proper slanted sound post is a luthieric form on innovation?
Chrisramo3 Thank you for your pic update.
It seems as if there is indeed a small tilt, if the tailpiece side of your bridge is perpendicular to the top plate as you mentioned.
Is it straight the other way round? (sight down the violin from the fingerboard to the tailpiece and look through the treble f hole). If so, where is it relatively to the foot of the bridge? is it aligned with it?
It may sound ok, but I am sure it will sound better if placed vertically. However since the angle is small, maybe it would be better to leave the operation to a luthier if possible. If you haven't done this before, mind that it could take longer time to do it than the luthier and Fiddlerman do in the video, and even longer to place it straight 🙂 I am not even discouraging you, it's just something to consider : maybe going diy would be longer than the trip to the luthier if it's the first time. Of course you can practice on a spare instrument as you said before.
@Jacques I am no luthier but if it's an innovation, I suppose its a time consuming one...imagine that one should calculate angles in multiple directions to ensure a proper fit... 🙂 Also moving the bridge could give us an idea as you proposed. I would have some little doubt however of whether it would properly depict the final outcome with the post perfectly straight, since on the one hand the bridge - post relationship would be better but on the other hand the bridge would be placed in a different position relatively to the top and the bass bar, plus the everlasting debate of different vibrating length and afterlength that we'll get...
@Fiddlerman , @Hermes, and @Jacques - Thanks again for all the great advice. I have tried to take some better pictures and made a comparison with my other violin. Since the difference is so slight I think I will take it to a local luthier and ask the same question. It is probably just in need of a slight adjustment if it needs one at all. I think will order a violin kit and work on putting one together ( if I do I'll post that in the forum) but I believe I will leave this issue to the pros.
@Fiddlerman - Thanks for pointing out the bridge position relative to the edge of the violin. I looked at the bridge very closely and it looks like it was tilted forward by a tiny bit. I straightened out the bridge so the back of the bridge was at right angles to the edge of the violin (corresponding to the horizontal line you drew) and the deep resonances came back immediately. The violin body was barely resonating before and it sounded ok but not great. Now when I bow across the strings I get the powerful resonances over the top and bottom plate. They sound deep and haunting (maybe poignant is a better word).
Most Users Ever Online: 231
Currently Browsing this Page:
Kevin M.: 1957
Guest Posters: 1
Newest Members:johnniegp16, Robertragma, Charlesweits, josefafu2, davidedith, johnniesh60
Administrators: Fiddlerman: 12316, KindaScratchy: 1687, BillyG: 1996