Welcome to our forum. A Message To Our New and Prospective Members . Check out our Forum Rules. Lets keep this forum an enjoyable place to visit.
Private messaging is working again.








LOL @Fiddlerman - I've always associated "song" with a vocalization ( something that someone sings - be it words, nonsense, la-la etc, foreign language, chants etc ) -and most definitely NOT from my perspective as an orchestrated or instrumental part/piece. o my mind, something called a "song" has to have a human vocalization - be it words, or just sounds.....
The voice is also an instrument (in a sense) and can in itself be awesome and inspiring. Pieces without vocalizations - I have always regarded as "tunes" ( or "pieces" - although I've also used "piece" to refer to both vocalized and instrumental things )
LOL - hard call to make though - and as you say - usage of a word ( be it right or wrong ) eventually becomes accepted ( I study languages as well - very sad I know - LOL - and it is quite amazing to see how word-usage (hence implied meaning) changes over time )
Thought provoking...
EDIT: Oh - in answer to your specific question - I would say no - if the original piece WAS s song with vocalization, but is being played as an instrumental - personally I would call it a "tune" or a "piece" - definitely not a "song"... but that's just me...
I seriously recommend not copying my mistakes. D'oh -
Please make your own, different mistakes, and help us all learn :-)

Honorary advisor
Regulars

The phrase "song has words!" always stuck with me but nowadays, in current portuguese, I think we use the word "music" a lot more to name everything (exception classical related, listed as pieces). For example, "did you hear that song on the radio?", we generally say "did you hear that music on the radio?" (literal translation) instead of canção (song).
In that case, vocalized piece played as an instrumental, I would refer to it as interpretation (of a song) in english.
I'm very curious to see other replies on this matter.

Regulars

I'm guilty of calling everything a song, whether it has words or not. I do know the difference, but I do it anyway. Kinda like how (in my neck of the woods) all soft drinks are referrd to as Coke, even if it's Dr. Pepper or Sprite. If you ask someone to bring you a Coke, they ask what kind. Blame it all on my roots. LOL!
Let the bow flow.

ElisaDalViolin said
The phrase "song has words!" always stuck with me but nowadays, in current portuguese, I think we use the word "music" a lot more to name everything (exception classical related, listed as pieces). For example, "did you hear that song on the radio?", we generally say "did you hear that music on the radio?" (literal translation) instead of canção (song).
Same to me, song has words. I refer to some pieces in Suzuki as songs because I learned them as songs, e.g., lightly row, twinkle, may song, go tell aunt Rhody, etc. and I play children's songs on violin:P
Most of the time I said "this piece of music" when it's played on radio. In Chinese, songs mean songs, and music is music, did I confuse you? yeah!

Regulars

I tend to refer to a piece of music that traditionally has words as a song, even if it is being played in an instrumental version. If I want to specifically refer to the sequence of notes without the words, I would call it the melody of the song.
If it is a piece of music that doesn't have traditional words, I would call it a tune (as in fiddle tunes) or a composition (classical music) or simply a piece of music.
So in Suzuki book 1, I call Go Tell Aunt Rhody and Long, Long Ago "songs", while Allegro and Minuet No. 3 are "pieces". I find it interesting to know whether a piece has vocal origins or not, and I enjoy learning the words even if I'm playing it on the violin and not singing it. For example, I had never heard Song of the Wind before I started studying the Suzuki book, but I have more fun playing it when I'm singing the words in my head!

"We sing a song", "we hum a tune".... when we hear birds chirping, generally they are in song, although there are no words to their melody.
We say, "now that's a catchy little tune",,,, are we talking about the words or the music, or both ? Or are we talking about the way the music was arranged with words to make it a song or just the melody without words.
I think it's just how it's used in our speech that deciphers or our perception of a tune or song. There can be tunes with words or tunes without words, but they are still "songs", IMO. The "tune" is the written music that makes a song a song and without a tune or written music, it now becomes a poem or is it poetry. Or prose if it doesn't rhyme.
We tune our instrument, we don't song it or sing it and there's generally no words to the sound of an "A"string, but we "tune" it anyway.
Most of us think of,"Wikipedia" as being the "holy grail" of information, but it too is written by people just like us who have their own opinions so without thinking we take it as being absolutely correct and it generally is, but this thread was started, to ask what we all thought. Now we all become amateur "Wiki's". LOL. and that's a good thing.
As for a "piece" of music. A piece according to "Merriam-Webster" as being a part of a whole. So when we play a piece of music, are we playing the whole song or just one bar.
My 4 cents.
Ken.

Very good topic..
I think I say songs or tunes interchangeably for anything.. I don't think I have ever given it a thought (lazy American!!!)
I can see how saying "songs" for a piece of music with no lyrics might make some go crazy.
I know a lot of violinist that call it as they see it.. and now maybe I see why.. if they are playing a sonata, or an etude, or a "piece" they are always proper in their terms... .. and if I am thinking to my conversations with them.. I don't think I ever hear them say they are playing a song.... I am sure to notice now... ha ha..
I think I am going to be a bit more precise. Not for any other reason than why not?
Vibrato Desperato.... Desperately seeking vibrato


@BillyG ha ha ha ha ha...
Good Point Diane.. does playing a song (something writtenwith lyrics) loose its "Song Status" just because it is being played musically????
Sorry Mr. Song, you've been downgraded to a Tune.... LOL
(musical bullying.......)
Vibrato Desperato.... Desperately seeking vibrato
1 Guest(s)

