Welcome to our forum. A Message To Our New and Prospective Members . Check out our Forum Rules. Lets keep this forum an enjoyable place to visit.
Private messaging is working again.








Regulars
Martele is where I think leading from the wrist is especially important. I don't know if I have a particular way to practice it, because it was one of the easiest bowing techniques for me (which makes it harder to explain), but... I think the key is leading with the wrist and rotating your wrist to lean into your index finger.

Regulars

Interesting you should ask this, cid, as my teacher went for martelé in lesson 1. But I think it was because I had already got into the habit of diffidently bowing sul tasto, and she wanted me to bow confidently and with sufficient pressure for bow speed on sounding point 3 (lol, I'm assuming that reference means the same to everyone). All she wanted, I think, was for me to feel the confidence to "let rip".
Since then we haven't used martelé at all, except on one accented note in Ole Bull's Shepherd Girl's Sunday.
Andrew
Verified human - the ignominy!

Regulars

Gordon Shumway said
she wanted me to bow confidently and with sufficient pressure for bow speed on sounding point 3 (lol, I'm assuming that reference means the same to everyone).
As long as it's 3, I guess it's fairly clear that you mean the middle point… would have been a different story if you'd said 2 or 4, though ;).
I'm trying to play with more pressure and father from the fingerboard too (and getting used to the richer sound). On a viola I find it somewhat harder "physically speaking".

Regulars


Regulars
The teacher's idea might just be to get you producing a positive start to each note.
I keep going on about this series of videos, but there's one that covers this very well here (that link should go straight to the relevant section at 9:32). It sounds like it's about dividing up the bow, but it covers how to get a positive attack on each note as well (starts at 11:12).

Regulars


Regulars

I like that video, Pierre. It also raises the subject, for me, of what is staccato?
On the piano the definition of staccato is that you play every note exactly half the length written. That's crucial in a piece like Debussy's Passepied. It's what's going on in the left hand here:
It (the Debussy) sounds dreadful staccatissimo.
But on the fiddle, I find my teacher trying to make me play notes much shorter than this. Again, is she just aiming for exaggeration, so I can decide on what's to my taste when I have mastered the technique?
Pierre's video is very interesting for its use of what I'd call staccato to stress the stressed start of each note. Except that Pierre's playing is subtler than that - he's giving a fast decay to each note so that it almost sounds staccato.
Then we have this Corelli piece (Op.5 no10 Sarabande), where the music calls for détaché, but Grumiaux seems to me to be playing staccato.
Partly it's because of the technical demand of the string jumping - I take it one should prefer to jump from the A string to the G string, or does a pro find jumping from E to G just as easy, Pierre?
If I were to play it that staccato, would I be accused of cheating?
Andrew
Verified human - the ignominy!

Honorary advisor
Regulars

Gordon Shumway said
I like that video, Pierre. It also raises the subject, for me, of what is staccato?It sounds dreadful staccatissimo.
But on the fiddle, I find my teacher trying to make me play notes much shorter than this. Again, is she just aiming for exaggeration, so I can decide on what's to my taste when I have mastered the technique?
@Gordon Shumway
I was not aware of the piano definition of staccato.
Here is a great definition of staccato for strings
Staccato bowingThe word Staccato and it's meaning comes from two words in Italian, Staccare (to detach), and Attaccare (to attack). Staccato is when each note intentionally sounds disconnected, signified by a shortened duration.
The idea is to play it short, but there does not seem to be a specific value for the length played. However, the notes should still have the same time value so that the count is still the same (4/4 time: quarter notes played staccato still hold 4 notes in a measure). Depending on tempo and mood, the duration of a note played staccato may vary.
- Pete -

Regulars

I just looked up staccato in Galamian and Fischer. They barely mention it, because one of the sources of confusion is that "staccato" means "bowed staccato" or "hooked bowing" to a lot of people, whereas I mean detached détaché, lol. Good, if the interpretation is up to the violinist, then bring it on!
Andrew
Verified human - the ignominy!
1 Guest(s)

