Welcome to our forum. A Message To Our New and Prospective Members . Check out our Forum Rules. Lets keep this forum an enjoyable place to visit.








Regulars





Regulars





Regulars


I'm an absolute newbie (as opposed to someone being modest); and I worked for several hours to get my vibrato going while trying to rock my finger back and forth; and I just can't get it yet. So, I too tried the string stretch like you would on a guitar and, as Terry mentioned, it does work more easily on the violin, but to my untrained ear, it sounds more like a "warping" of the note than a vibrato of the note. But Terry, I've had the exact same question you posed, is it a valid vibrato.

Pro advisor
Regulars
I can say that if it works for you and it sounds great to others it is ok.
I've been playing guitar for 30+yrs and playing violin since only this last summer. I'm developing some cool guitar style vibrato for violin but the violin neck is so small that I do understand the difference in vibrato techniques.

Regulars




Yeah, after trying it a few times, this kind of " warbling" does seem a bit 1 dimensional as it relies only on the distance /amplitude (if that is the correct word) between a string on the fingerboard to off the board , compared to the tonal variation given by rolling the finger back and forth on the knuckle.
I am amazed at how old people of my age are.....

Regulars





Advanced member
cdennyb said
Start with FM's videos on finger vibrato first, then progress to the hand and then to the arm vibrato...
I just started last night trying the arm vibrato and I couldn't really make anything interesting happen. I assumed FM wanted us to go from arm to hand to finger since the videos were ordered that way, but now that you mention it, I think it might be easier to start with the fingers and work the other way?
I'll give it another go tonight. I've got a few slow waltz pieces I want to learn and it would be really nice to fit some vibrato in there to make them interesting.

Regulars




an interesting insight into what I was trying to explain.
Cant find it again, but a guy called Todd Ehle, said that maybe 2 from 30 of his studies could suddenly do vibrato by applying this "impulse" method. Apparantly if one gets really frantic with it, the vertical movement of your hand becomes lateral "proper" vibrato.
I am amazed at how old people of my age are.....

Honorary advisor
Regulars

Terry said
Yes it's quite clear as a vibrato, I guess I picked it up from the small attempts I tried on the guitar, but due to the lack of frets it seems easier on a violin.
I'll try and do a video of it
That would be great if you can do a video because it sounds sort of like the kind of "vibrato" that I sometimes find myself doing and that sort of came naturally to me. However, I am trying to learn the regular arm, wrist, finger vibrato techniques.

Pro advisor
Regulars
I would love to see a video as well. I've really been practicing vibrato correctly for the violin lately but I do have that natural guitar style vibrato and I know that won't work in the long run and as cd mentioned there is just not enough room on the violin for what I think you are mentioning ? The violin neck is just too damn small

Regulars





Pro advisor
Regulars
1 Guest(s)

