Fiddlerman said
I voted for the Gewa, but give us a call if you want a better price than what you have already found. We are very competitive.

Why do you like the Gewa Venetian over the other cases? I don't see it available on Fiddlershop either. Are you able to do a special order for those?

Hermes said
Between those cases, I would also go for the venetian, hands down. I sometimes overanalyse things , so I would perhaps install an extra neck rest with a respective velcro strap. But I am sure the whole suspension system works as is.

Overall to explain my preference

1) it has a more "padded" lid if you take a closer look, and that could translate to better protection, at least in our minds.

2) Four bow holders instead of less (like the half-moon an the pedi). I've never used more than two, no matter how many bows I've had simultaneously, but hey, it's good to have a spare place, right?

3) It is a composite case (gewa call i thermo shell or sthg like this). Just by habit, I would prefer plywood, but it still beats fibreglass and aluminium reinforcement  in my mind.

4) I somehow prefer it over this particular Baker, since it holds the instrument straight and not diagonally. Nothing important, it's just my preference.

5) I love how the place where the back of the violin goes is shaped. It seems more tidy that just having a block of foam in the front and one in the back.

5). Have you seen this stunning interior lining? I would not resist.
6) Did I mention this blanket that is attached to the case? It's the detail in this case that caught my eye.  

While I don't normally go for pretty asthetics, I have to admit the Venetian is pretty as heck. Just for the interior, it jumps up to the top for being the nicest looking. Looking at the Venetian, it seems to be held down by the foam pad on the top of the case.

1. Padded lid? Are talking about the padded section that keeps the violin down? Or something else?
2. So long as the case has at least 2 holders, I'll be fine. I know I won't carry, or most likely won't, more than 2 since I would only bring my best to carry around.
3. Composite is quite fantastic. If carbon fiber or fiberglass is created correctly, it can take some very high amounts of shock and force without any contortion. Problem is it will abruptly fail after reaching past its ultimate tensile strength. Wood is nice in that it has very good force protection with durability. Either way, doesn't matter since I'm not picky so long as it works well and correctly.
4. I noticed that with my BK-4030. Its fine, but I particularly would rather have the violin sit flat and parallel to the case.
5. As I said, the interior is easily one of, if not the most, beautiful I have seen in a case. Its also why deep down, I increased my price I am willing to spend.
6. If execution and finish is good, the little detail will be wonderful. Though, I completely forgot about that added bonus.

So that being said, I presume you, like Pierre, recommend me going with the Gewa Venetian case?

Hermes said

About the lid: No, I refer to the shape of the lid. Usually you have from outside to inside, a canvas cover, the material of the case (fiberglass, wood, whatever) some lining and that's it. in the venetian, there seems to be some stuff (foam maybe? ) behind the bow storage in particular. That makes the lid thicker, and I had come across a review once, stating this "bonus"
About the material: You are right about the fiberglass. This composite shell of the gewa gives the impression of being a little more "cushiony" or "fluffy" or whatever the word might be.
P.S. You could also take a look to the Gewa Maestro. It's similar to the Venetian, but with more simple lining and I guess a little cheaper, if the budget is an issue. But this lining, is worth the extra money. I guess.
Yes, I would prefer the gewa than the other options. In your budget I think it's a safe choice.   

Believe it, man. I already purchased the Gewa Venetian from Quinn Violins. I would have purchased it from Fiddlershop but they didn't have it on their website. I called earlier in the day about getting a price but they didn't back to be on the price. Since I need to decide on which case I want pretty soon, I just dropped the amount.

I have a couple carbon fiber longboards so I am used to the strengths and weakness of carbon fiber and similar composites. They are strong, stiff, but fragile. So long the impact isn't something along the lines of a knife tip or a pointed end, it will hold up to some heavy abuse. Fiberglass, since it is held by polyester, can flex more than carbon fiber and has some bonuses to that. If Fiberglass is held by epoxy, similar to that of carbon fiber, it will become what is known as G-10 (in the simple sense). If you built a case that was about 1/4 - 1/2 inch thick, which would be the heaviest case out there, it might be one of the strongest against impact damage.

Anyways, aside from my rant, I like the Venetian because of the style and I'll pay a bit more for the fancy and nicer insides. So long as it protects well and lasts me a long time, I will be happy.

Fiddlerman said

Gurashieruro said
Believe it, man. I already purchased the Gewa Venetian from Quinn Violins. I would have purchased it from Fiddlershop but they didn't have it on their website. I called earlier in the day about getting a price but they didn't back to be on the price. Since I need to decide on which case I want pretty soon, I just dropped the amount.

Who did you talk to? I'll get on their case.....

We moved to a new building on Friday and were preparing all week. This could have been the issue. Hopefully we can help you next time.

Pierre  

Don't worry about, Pierre. I remember you telling me that you guys were working on a new building so I presumed that's why he didnt get back to me. It was just a shame since I like giving you my business over someone else like, Quinn Violins, since you guys have given me some really good advice.

Though, I still want to purchase a pernambuco bow after I do those upgrades to my Artist. Still haven't forgotten. What do you think about Ipe wood vs Pernambuco wood for bows?

Fiddlerman said
I'm not as much worried about it as I am concerned if we are loosing business to customers for neglecting them.
In any case, I'm sorry that we let the ball drop.  

You're fine Pierre. Things slip through, it happens. It is especially true with the upgrades you guys were doing. Anyways, I have since sent back the Gewa Venetian since I hated how badly built the one I got was. Instead, I purchased a Negri Venezia.