I looked at tons of reviews, then stumbled upon Fiddlerman.  Based on so many positive reviews, I decided to go with Fiddlerman.  At first, I couldn't decide which violin to go with because I didn't want to invest money in a student violin, only to upgrade months later.  Also, I read several reviews where more advanced violins are easier to play.  Since I'm new to the violin and reading notes, I was leaning towards getting a violin that was easier to play.   Fortunately, I'm local and I met with Pierre and Mike.  I was able to hold the violin and draw a bow across the strings.  I couldn't believe how much easier it was to produce a sound from the strings on a more advanced violin, than a starter violin! Since I am local to their shop, they suggested renting.  I decided to rent before investing alot of money in something that I may not stick with. Another thing about Pierre and Mike is that they are very accommodating.  I wanted a particular sounding violin and Pierre found it for me.  I can't wait until my workday is over so that I can tackle the G string notes, again (day 2 of practice).  

I realize that my response is not definitive as to which violin to buy, however, I don't believe that you will go wrong with purchasing a violin from Fiddlerman.  The violins look and sound amazing!