Welcome to our forum. A Message To Our New and Prospective Members . Check out our Forum Rules. Lets keep this forum an enjoyable place to visit.









Regulars
Nice to meet you. Good interview.
Opportunity is often missed because it wears suspenders and looks like hard work.



Regulars

I really enjoyed your interview ratvn. I watch all your vids > SWEET!!! > Your passion for this instrument is deep and I felt that before reading about you. It always seemed to come out in your playing. Your are truly a player, a musician > one who brings sounds from the heart.
ratvn > ROCKS!!!!!!!!!

Honorary tenured advisor
Regulars
Nice meeting you Robert, and I love your survival story. Having spent many years working in Oncology and Palliative Care, I really love the attitudes of some of my patients ... 'This cancer won't get me!'
I was interested to hear you tune your violin a semitone down, I didn't know that was possible. Is it just for particular strings, or your general preference?
Bravo my friend!
If you think you can, or you think you can't, you're probably right.

Honorary tenured advisor
Regulars

Thanks all for your encouragement and support.
It's a privilege and my pleasure to get interviewed. Thanks FM for putting it up.
You All a Great Family. You All >>>ROCKS!!!
@Robyn.fnq: thank you for your encouragement. I'm not off the hook yet, still on their radar scope and hopefully I won't fall off their screen that quick.
the semitone tuning down is a still a debate of whether it sounds better so whatever works for you is good. Some of Baroque pieces were played with A=415Hz, with gut strings and original violin design, instead of higher neck angle, string tension to make for better projection, solo that needed to stand out from the rest of orchestra instruments. The standard tuning today, mostly, is A=440, in USA, as for piano and other instruments, but there are countries that specify it differently, A=415 for example.
It's very simple to carry out if your tuner has preset/adjustable for it (there are also other methods). My tuner has preset for A from 410 to 480 Hz. So just set it at A=415Hz and then proceed doing everything normally as one would, from tuning to play sheet music to fingering as nothing happened. At the end, if one would compare it to an A=440 tuning, it would sound a semitone down, a transposition/modulation, like playing in different key, ie instead of C minor, it's B minor.
The only inconveniences with it are when playing with some fix tuning instruments, piano/keyboard/others for one, playing in group project in which there is a set of tuning pitch and tempo to follow, or playing along with an audio from youtube tuning at A=440.
A=415 for violin is not just a transposition, IMHO, as there would be less string tension, string/bridge sound transfering/coupling would emphasize the mid and low range while reducing the high, thus would make it sound a bit sweeter/richer less harsh, and of course lower volume/projection, which is better for me as to not disturb others, also less string tension means it's easier for my fingering and strings, and I've done it that way since a few weeks into learning, up until now as general practice with quite a few different string sets. I would be happily to retune mine up to 440 if I have some one to play with. As for youtube tunes, there is Amazing Slow Downer (for pitch shifting) which is not only for practicing but also can output a .wav file with new setting/tuning, that can be input to Audacity to play along with (for multi-track recording) so everything would be in tune. In fact, all of my posted audio were with my violin tuning at A=415Hz while the audio tracks were at A=440Hz originally (then tuned down using Amazing Slow Downer to shift to the required pitch).
If you like to, you can also give it a try for a few days to see. I also have one violin tuned to A=440Hz just to follow a quick youtube tune/or some similar, so I don't have to go through all the trouble of retuning the audio piece to fit in with my violin. Whatever works for you will be best.
Robert

Honorary tenured advisor
Regulars
Thanks Robert, that's very interesting. I use BP Minus for the same purpose, and was a bit confused about pitch changing, but have discovered each number lowered is equal to one semitone, so I suppose that would equate to A=415, as you explained.
I might try that with my silent electric Cecilio, as the strings are not as high quality as my acoustic, and I use the electric for most practice to spare my family and neighbours. I have a tuner/metronome that's adjustable in pitch, so it should be straightforward.
It's worth a try, and as you say, might sound more mellow.
If you think you can, or you think you can't, you're probably right.

Honorary tenured advisor
Regulars



Regulars
Hi Robert @ratvn
Nice interview. Very interesting.
You said you play some 'ethnic' insuments. Do you have any experience in anything like the Chinese 'urhu'
I bought one back from China this year and things aren't going all that well with it.
Seen it all. Done it all. Can't remember most of ..... What was I saying????

Honorary tenured advisor
Regulars

Thank you, Toni, @coolpinkone, and John, @Ferret for your encouragement and support.
@Ferret, John, I have a Vietnamese version of the Erhu in my instrument collection. It's very similar in construction (Erhu was originally from a minor ethnic group, near China).
My teacher at that time, about 20 yrs ago, only showed me the basic tuning/playing but I did not pay much attention to it as I was concentrating on some other instruments, Zither, monochord and later, a 2 stringed round shape lute.
Since the instrument was designed to play some particular musics, using it for western tunes requires retuning/adaptation to western musical scale, and the tunes are to be transposed/modulated to the instrument particular tonic pitch/note.
It should not be harder than playing violin. The Vietnamese one was adapted to play traditional musics, but it also could play some western tunes being a fiddle.
There are several ways to tune the instrument, depend on the type of music being played (Vietnamese traditional musics employed several tuning systems), and the one closest to western scale would have the tuning in perfect fifth (your favorite, John), a perfect fourth would also work (which is a fifth at one octave lower).
So one way of tuning it is G D, (which is the same as violin two lower string tuning and fingering), with tunes all transposed to Dm and its relative F, or for easier reading, Em and G (one sharp). To cover the higher end, being a 2 stringed instrument, it's usually played in 3rd or 4th position if needed to.

Honorary advisor
Regulars

1 Guest(s)

