Welcome to our forum. A Message To Our New and Prospective Members . Check out our Forum Rules. Lets keep this forum an enjoyable place to visit.
Private messaging is working again.








Advanced member
Hello all,
I was watching violin covers on Youtube and I came across this woman's YouTube channel. She is an excellent player however, she seems to hold her bow really high up compared to what I've seen others do. On top of that, she also seems to be actually holding the hairs in her grasp. You can see an example of what I am talking about here:
When imagining how I m to hold a bow when I do finally start playing violin for the first time, it seems like an uncomfortable thought for me as a bow is so long and from what I have read, you are to hold it down towards the end with a light grasp. That to me seems difficult to grasp. The way the woman in the video holds her bow seems so much more comfortable in theory. Is it realistic to actually hold a bow like that?
Any thoughts on the this would be greatly appreciated. Sorry if I rambled. I am good for that. Was trying to get my thoughts across in the best way.
Thanks!!

Regulars
Baroque violinists and some fiddlers hold the bow up there (they don't hold the bow hairs, though)... I do when playing Baroque music, but not when playing music from other eras.
That bow hold helps with some of the stylistic effects that were common in Baroque music (e.g. where you're supposed to lift a little at the beginning and end of each note), and some find it a little more agile. But it also limits expression in many ways, which is why it isn't the standard bow hold.

Advanced member
AndrewH said
Baroque violinists and some fiddlers hold the bow up there (they don't hold the bow hairs, though)... I do when playing Baroque music, but not when playing music from other eras.
That bow hold helps with some of the stylistic effects that were common in Baroque music (e.g. where you're supposed to lift a little at the beginning and end of each note), and some find it a little more agile. But it also limits expression in many ways, which is why it isn't the standard bow hold.
Hello Andrew,
That was an excellent answer. Thank you for explaining that to me. I actually was not aware there are different bow handling for different play styles. Makes sense. Thanks!!

Member

I dropped by a long-established and highly-recommended Irish session in Evanston (IL) a few weeks ago. Nine violins, 1 viola, 8 other instruments. Players seemed good to excellent. EVERY SINGLE ONE with a bow held the bow way up on the stick. Could this be standard in some circles?
Only other place I've seen it was at a performance, on historic instruments, of early Scottish music (http://timandjeremy.com )--but those guys had shortish bows curved the other way, obviously historic.
I get out so little I'm just beginning to collect orienting "data" like this... would like to hear what anyone knows about who does this, and why.
1 Guest(s)

