Good playing, syke sun!   You are doing very well, especially for 5 months!

I don't think the reverb either made or broke it.  I think it sounded nice with the reverb, though.   

A thought on the reverb for you, though.  Reverb tends to make an instrument sound more distant.  So having reverb on the violin and not the guitar makes the guitar seem closer to the listener with the violin a distance away.  I personally would have probably used a little reverb on the guitar as well, so boith instruments feel like they are at about the same distance from the listener and "in the same room".

But the way you did it sounded good, and I think it maybe gave the violin a little more of a "dream" quality than the guitar, which may be just what you intended.

It was good recording and playing.  Very pleasant to listen to! 

@syke_sun: Yes, things like reverb are good for that.  Most of us do not get to practice in a big hall or auditorium, and the acoustics of such places help the sound of the instrument.  When we watch videos of professional players, they are usually in places with much better acoustics than the rooms of our houses or reverb and other effects have been added by a professional sound engineer.

Of course that is not all of what makes them sound better than us, but it is a part of it.  So adding a little reverb can help us to actually hear how we sound sompared to the professionals, and so it can be a learning tool and often a bit of encouragement.

Most of the presets for Audacity will have a control named "mix" or "wet/dry".  Adjusting that will adjust the amount of reverb sound and the amount of plain sound.  As I recall, most of the presets in Audacity start at about 25% on that control, which is enough reverb that it is very easy to hear that an effect is being used.  If you use a bit less, like 12% or even a little less, then the listener's attention will not focus so much on the effect, but on your playing.  It makes it less obvious to the ear.

If you have been using Audacity enough to try something a little more advanced, I can explain a trick you may like.  

Highlight the track of the instrument you recorded that you want to try some reverb on. 

Then use "edit/duplicate"

That will give you a copy of the original track.  Then you use reverb on the copy instead of the original, and set the reverb's "mix" or "wet/dry" to 100%.

Now you can play back both tracks and adjust the volume of the new track (which will be all reverb) to get the sound exactly to your taste, instead of trying to guess how much wet/dry to use on the preset. 

That is a little more "professional", since it will give better control over the sound.  It also leaves the original track unaltered, which makes it easier to go back to what you started from if some effect you try makes a change you decide later that you didn't like.