Check out our Forum Rules. Lets keep this forum an enjoyable place to visit.
@martind welcome to the FM forum. I've never used d'Addario strings, but I'm sure someone here is familiar with them. I've found that FiddlerMan strings are similar to Dominants and have used them on all of my violins. Good luck and keep posting your progress while you and your child learn together (read your profile that your starting Suzuki).
Bob in Lone Oak, Texas
Testing strings are so difficult since you need to have fresh sets of the one you are comparing to as well. In other words, it's not fair to remove old strings and test new fresh strings. Better to test new fresh strings back to back. Which means putting on and taking off the strings a lot. Also, testing strings for up to a week will give a better idea of what they sound like after breaking them in.
Oh yes, I can see the problem @Fiddlerman
I imagine that a good test would involve having 2 violins of similar quality to test the strings. Plus, you might want to keep the strings on the hypothetical violins for enough time to settle and maintain their tune so you can compare their tone and sound after they've been on the violin for a bit, since new strings can change their sound over time.
Apart from this, I suppose the other way to determine string quality and/or how to chose the strings that produce the sound you want is to try them at a violin shop or with a luthier if you have access to one.
I am actually not looking forward to when I have to search for and change strings. However, I do want to be proactive and not wait until something catastrophic happens like a string breaking or something. So I appreciate all the advise that everyone offers here!
- Pete -
Wow!! I agree! It would be a pain!
Yeah, I am not looking forward to changing. The strings I am using are my first strings and I am used to them. So changing them will be a pain as far as getting used to. My first change I will have a professional do. I don't feel confident enough yet to try that myself. But the selection of strings I will rely heavily on the advise of my music teacher and the luthier to help with.
Not to mention the $100 or so that I will need to have.
It's all part of the life of a violinist, right!
- Pete -
my Luthier got a set of Ascente sent to him, didn't get around to trying them, so his wife gave them to me to try out.
like Helicore, the diameter of the D string is smaller than the A string...one of the several reasons I don't like Helicore. BUT, the Ascente are warm to medium warm with a very nice tone.
However, I didn't like the A string that much on my fiddle. I didn't think it balanced that well with the the D & G. a bit too aggressive, louder, brighter, more metallic. So I put my Evah Gold A back on. it blended great and smoothed everything out.
So I'll only be using the Ascente G, D, and prolly E, with the Evah Gold A. Very happy with what the Ascente G & D did to my fiddle over all, and plan to keep them on. previously I had Evah Gold D and Violino G. I have an Evah Gold (silver) G but it was a bit too much bottom end so I used the Violino G.
anyhoo (somewhat surprised) the Ascente G & D took out some grainy-ness over all, focused every thing up, and somewhat improved my over all tone. I really wasn't expecting this from a lower cost D'Addario string. Having said that, if I HAD to use the Ascente A string, I'd just go back to what I had.
You can see in this vid that the A string looks (and imo sounds) different than the others. Maybe wouldn't make that much difference on other fiddles or to different players.
I'll be waiting to hear what @Fiddlerman thinks of them.
"Striving to attain Mediocrity"
@martind I've been using them for about 6 months now and I really like them. I'm still using all 4 Ascente strings and I can concur with what @bluesviolin said about the G & D strings and the A string. The Ascente E is warm and sweet all the way up the string. The Ascente strings took out the buzzing of the Prelude G & D strings that was really annoying. I think I'll try @bluesviolin recommendation for the A string replacement next time it breaks.
Most Users Ever Online: 231
Currently Online: yellowdresses, BillyG
Currently Browsing this Page:
Kevin M.: 1969
Guest Posters: 2
Newest Members:thomasea4, mablewd60, esmaeil78, esmaeill78, amparoma16, bruceeb18
Administrators: Fiddlerman: 13230, KindaScratchy: 1721, BillyG: 2396